The Gourmet Oasis for Extra Virgin Olive Oil & Balsamic Vinegars

Welcome to Our Exquisite Online Emporium! With over 20 years of experience in our Brick & Mortar Store, we proudly present a Gourmet Haven for Cold Press, Extra Virgin Olive Oil and Balsamic Vinegar

Step into a World where Passion, Tradition and Quality Converge, Creating an Exceptional Culinary Experience. Our Carefully Curated Collection Features an Extensive Array of Premium Olive Oils and Meticulously Crafted Balsamic Vinegars from Around the Globe.

Our Mission

To provide exceptional olive oils, balsamic vinegars, and gourmet products that elevate culinary experiences, delighting and inspiring our customers with the finest flavors from around the world.

"The oils and vinegars are amazing!"

Trenton, MI

"Great service, fast shipping, and very reasonable prices for products of such quality!"

Los Angeles, California

"Product quality is top-notch. Shipping is fast. Customer service is AMAZING. I honestly can’t recommend them enough."

Lincoln, Virginia

"Mind blowing assortment of Flavored Oils, Breads and Cheeses"

J.P. - (Store Review)
North Carolina


Kelly Kary


Upon relocating from the Detroit Suburbs with its various ethnic markets to the Sarasota area I noticed that there was a significant void in my ability to find Great Culinary products and a real lack of GOOD Extra Virgin Olive Oil.  Thus the Sarasota Olive Oil Company was born in an up and coming neighborhood in Sarasota where we stayed for over 5 years.  

From there we moved out to the Beautiful City of Anna Maria to "anchor" a new redevelopment of Pine Avenue.  We have been in our current location approaching 14 years!

If you are ever in the Tampa, Bradenton, Sarasota Area we are located on the Beautiful Island of Anna Maria.  Our store is the Island Purveyor of Extra Virgin Olive Oils, Balsamics, Wonderful Cheeses and a Curated Collection of  Small Production Wines!  

We are Here!

401 Pine Avenue, Anna Maria FL 34216

We are Open

Monday - Saturday

11 a.m. - 5 p.m.

Closed on Sunday